AI search summaries cannibalise academic publishers’ web traffic – Times Higher Education

Resources for
academics and university staff
Everything you need for each step
of your study abroad journey
Scholarly publishers must highlight the “blood, sweat and tears” that researchers expend in producing original and robust content as readers increasingly turn to artificial intelligence-generated summaries of studies, a conference has heard.
Speaking at the Academic and Professional Publishing Conference, part of London Book Fair, Oxford University Press (OUP) product strategy director John Campbell explained how the launch of Google’s AI-powered search summaries had led to a 90 per cent drop in click-throughs to some of its academic services.
Discussing what he called the advent of “zero-click journeys” for academic publishers, Campbell explained how half of all Google searches which referenced information in OUP’s own platform, Oxford Academic, now appeared with an AI-generated description next to them.
In this context, investment in such search platforms might be seen as having a “terrible return on investment”, but the hit-and-miss nature of these AI descriptions – often producing inaccurate and potentially inflammatory material – highlighted “the core principles of what we built in the first place”, Campbell explained.
For instance, a Google AI search referencing an Oxford Academic paper falsely claimed that Barack Obama was the first Muslim president of the US after it misconstrued a headline from an academic paper, said Campbell.
With this kind of error now common, it was increasingly important for publishers to link studies “back to the original author” and explain “how we relate [studies] to the blood, sweat and tears that happen in the lab”,  he said, adding it was admittedly “hard to define and tell…the transformative story about the research [process]” .
Speaking to Times Higher Education at the event, Campbell said publishers should “expect the way that most people get basic facts will change”, but that publishers were still crucial for more in-depth inquiries that would establish the “grounds for truth”.
“The industry needs to tell the story of research better – what research is and what the research process is,” he said.
In this regard, publishers needed to evidence more clearly the impact of research publication – a role now performed by Sensus Impact, a product launched last year by OUP, which provides information to funders about a publication’s reach, impact on future research and societal impact including attention metrics.
“We need to show staff are having an impact, using different types of metrics” he said. “Publishers shouldn’t leave this others – they need to be in the middle of the spider’s web when it comes to impact.”
jack.grove@timeshighereducation.com
Why register?
Or subscribe for unlimited access to:
Already registered or a current subscriber? Login
Academics tell Elsevier that they recognise the potential of generative AI but want to see their concerns addressed
UK government’s Prevent strategy is ‘true threat to free speech’ in universities, argues Hepi pamphlet by former US government civil rights official
Nobel laureate says discussing vapid AI answers can help students understand true scientific rigour
Global survey of peer reviewers reveals deep distrust towards ChatGPT, with some calling for a complete ban on its use in research and academia
AI is here to stay but universities must teach students to use it responsibly, say Duncan Brumby, Anna Cox, Advait Sarkar and Sandy Gould
Universities should prioritise ensuring that assessments are ‘assessing what we mean to assess’ rather than letting conversations be dominated by discussions around cheating
One in four students tell Hepi they use text generated by tools such as ChatGPT in submitted work
The recent arrest of accreditation council members only underlines that competence of regulation is as much of an issue as its degree, says Pushkar
Subscribe to Times Higher Education
As the voice of global higher education, THE is an invaluable daily resource. Subscribe today to receive unlimited news and analyses, commentary from the sharpest minds in international academia, our influential university rankings analysis and the latest insights from our World Summit series.

source

About The Author

admin

See author's posts