Undermining academia – The Express Tribune

US
.
The Sindh government's recent move to broaden the eligibility criteria for the appointment of vice chancellors at public universities has become a cause for concern among the academic community and stakeholders in higher education. Allowing non-academic professionals, bureaucrats and retired executives to assume what should be the most academically driven positions within our universities undermines the very essence of higher education and its commitment to research and scholarship.
While the government tries to frame the backlash as meritless, arguing that VCs are largely administrative positions, the evidence is overwhelming to the contrary. VCs are not only the administrative heads of universities, but are also pivotal in shaping academic policies and fostering an environment conducive to learning and research. They chair critical academic bodies that influence curriculum development, research agendas and the overall direction of academic institutions. Entrusting this role to individuals without a robust academic background compromises the integrity of these functions.
The Sindh government's argument that the change is aimed at expanding the pool of candidates and improving governance within institutions is heavily flawed. Education is a specialised field, as are many aspects of the bureaucracy. Just as an award-winning physicist would be out of their depth running the interior ministry, we cannot have an unqualified federal secretary, no matter how competent in their own field, imposed on academia. Candidates who lack experience in academia may inadvertently overlook the unique challenges that universities face, prioritising bureaucratic efficiency over educational excellence.
If the goal actually is only improving governance, rather than appointing loyalists, the government could just as easily improve compensation and other terms of employment to attract better-qualified prospects, instead of planting outsiders whose credentials will never live up to the job.
COMMENTS
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
Updated 1 hour ago
Trump dismissed a journalist’s question about visiting the plane crash site, mocking the suggestion.
Updated 1 hour ago
Logan and Jake Paul announced their new reality show, Paul American, premiering on Max on March 27.
Updated 2 hours ago
Rapper Too Short shared tearful videos on social media after his brother, was fatally shot in East Oakland.
Updated 2 hours ago
Bruno Mars dismisses speculation about a $50M gambling debt as his new track with Sexyy Red dominates charts.
Undermining academia
DeepSeek disruption
Legislation with vendetta
HIV's silent spread
Cosmetic steps
Need to get back to talks
Weather system to bring rain and temperature drop across Pakistan
Govt employees get free electricity worth Rs6,000 monthly: Energy minister
'Pakistan needs $100b financing'
Bidadoo employee April Martinson fired after calling immigrants ‘sub-human’
Maryam Nawaz sets deadline for Rawalpindi Ring Road completion
US investors keen to invest billions in Pakistan, says delegation head
Acrimony over the right to Indus water
AI at the helm: a bold roadmap for transforming universities
Tech politics and Trump 2.0
The microplastics menace
Transformative potential of CPEC and Gwadar
Why I support Trump's immigration policy
Plot no.5 Express News Building Near KPT FLY over Karachi Pakistan
This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, redistributed or derived from. Unless otherwise stated, all content is copyrighted © 2025 The Express Tribune.

source

About The Author

admin

See author's posts